Windscribe vs Surfshark: which VPN should you actually pick?

A side-by-side on price, jurisdiction, devices, and what each service is genuinely good at.

Measured head-to-head: Windscribe vs Surfshark

Our own captures for Windscribe and Surfshark, side by side, with every gap and every limit.

MeasuredWindscribeSurfshark
Baseline download (VPN off)295 Mbps296 Mbps
Nearest Europe: serverParis Jardin (WireGuard 443)Manchester
Nearest Europe: download222 Mbps (75%)210 Mbps (71%)
Nearest Europe: upload178 Mbps181 Mbps
Nearest Europe: ping44 ms79 ms
Long-distance US: download203 Mbps (69%)203 Mbps (69%)
Long-distance US: ping108 ms112 ms
DNS leak test captured captured
WebRTC leak test captured captured
BBC iPlayer captured captured
Netflixnot capturednot captured

Takeaway: on the Europe route Windscribe kept 75% of its baseline against 71% for Surfshark (a gap of 4 points); on the US route 69% against 69%. Gaps this small are inside the noise of a single run, so we do not call a winner on speed.

Same line and machine with a fresh baseline for each VPN. Server country and protocol can differ; one run per route.

All Windscribe captures →

Questions people ask

Short answers, based on our own captures and the data on this site.

Which is faster, Windscribe or Surfshark?

On the nearest-European route Windscribe delivered 222 Mbps against Surfshark's 210 Mbps (75% vs 71% of each baseline); on the US route 203 vs 203 Mbps. One run each, so treat small gaps as noise.

Is Windscribe or Surfshark better for streaming?

We captured Windscribe playing BBC iPlayer. For Surfshark we captured BBC iPlayer. Missing results mean not captured, not failed.

Were both tested under the same conditions?

Same line and machine with a fresh baseline for each, but the server country and protocol can differ; the table lists them.

Where can I see the raw captures?

The screenshots and recordings for Windscribe are on its tests pages. We publish captures only for the VPN each site is about.

WindscribeSurfshark
Price$9/mo, or $69/yr ($5.75/mo) – plus a pay-per-location Build-A-Plan from $1/location/moTypically the cheapest of the major VPNs on long-term plans
JurisdictionCanada (a Five Eyes member – worth weighing against jurisdictions like Panama or Switzerland)Netherlands
Free planFree plan with a genuinely usable monthly data allowance (rare among major VPNs)No ongoing free plan
Simultaneous devicesUnlimited simultaneous devices on paid plansUnlimited simultaneous devices
Server footprint69+ countries, 112+ cities3,200+ servers in 100 countries
TransparencyOpen-source apps, published transparency reports and a public court-order track recordIndependently audited apps and no-logs policy
Ad/tracker blockerR.O.B.E.R.T. – DNS-level blocker for ads, trackers, malware and more, toggled by categoryCleanWeb (ads, trackers, malware)

Where Surfshark pulls ahead

Unlimited device connections on a single subscription – the same unlimited-device perk Windscribe offers. On price: typically the cheapest of the major vpns on long-term plans. On jurisdiction, Surfshark is based in Netherlands, which some privacy-conscious users will prefer over Windscribe's Canadian, Five-Eyes jurisdiction – though jurisdiction alone says little about day-to-day server performance.

Where Windscribe pulls ahead

Windscribe's free tier is a genuine, usable product rather than a trial, its R.O.B.E.R.T. blocker gives per-category control that most built-in ad/tracker blockers don't, and Build-A-Plan pricing lets you pay only for the countries you use instead of one flat rate. For unlimited simultaneous devices on Surfshark versus unlimited simultaneous devices on paid plans on Windscribe, household use cases with many devices will often favor whichever service doesn't force an upgrade just to add one more phone or laptop.

Who each one is really for

If you already know you want Surfshark's specific strengths – unlimited device connections on a single subscription – the same unlimited-device perk Windscribe offers – and you're comfortable paying from day one, it's a reasonable pick. If you'd rather test a real product for free first, want granular per-category ad/tracker blocking, or only need coverage in a handful of countries, Windscribe's free tier and Build-A-Plan pricing are worth trying before you commit to either service annually.

Our verdict

Both offer unlimited devices, so the real decision comes down to price versus free tier: Surfshark usually wins on long-term price, Windscribe wins if you want to test the service for free first or only need a few server locations.

See Today's Best VPN Deals